One of the things that tends to happen when we work in frontline service organisations – in particular service organisations like fire, ambulance, police and defence, is that often a conservative risk assessment is applied if a member identifies that something they experienced in the course of their work, has affected them negatively.
Say you attended a particularly difficult incident, then found that you were having nightmares or flashbacks, or something noticeably different was happening in your life as a result of attending that incident. What tends to happen is the organisation will automatically stand you down.
They think they’re helping
Traditionally, the organisation’s approach is to support the member to take a bit of rest, get support or take time off. But often what it does is makes these people feel they are being punished for being honest about their experience, and how that experience has affected them because they are then prevented from doing the role that they love.
Not surprisingly, this approach has meant that members don’t disclose these things… They bottle the issues up, inside themselves.
I often talk to organisations about whether there is an opportunity to undertake less conservative risk assessments. If we encouraged an open dialogue about mental health within the organisation, we would be able to let people talk about how something was affecting them. We would also give them the autonomy to decide whether or not the impact that it was having on their personal lives was impacting their role.
This is not something that we have traditionally done. Service organisations always take a conservative approach, that the member might represent a risk to others. This is something that even the psychology profession has done. Assumed that a person is not operating at the top of their game, therefore we stand them down until we think that they are okay.
We do need to make sure that we’ve done that risk assessment, to ensure that they are not a harm for others, but it should not automatically be assumed that they will cause harm. In reality, when you can build a culture where people are open about how experiences have affected them, you create a culture whereby people feel comfortable and safe acknowledging their emotion.
That’s not a bad thing
We know as human beings that when we experience challenges and difficulties, it impacts us. We need to be talking to each other about how these events happen to us and sometimes one experience can remind us of another experience. Just because that might make us feel sad or upset, impact our sleep, or we might be finding that it’s causing us to feel a bit distressed, is not necessarily a reason to stand somebody down.
If we don’t start changing the way we do this risk assessment and stop forcing people to be punished (as they perceive it), then we’re never going to be able to change it.
It all comes back to giving people autonomy and the insight to know that they can be open and honest about how their experiences have impacted their mental health. But also let them decide what is the right thing for them to do to make it better, and let them heal.
If we educate well enough around what to look for, then they get to decide whether they need time off or not, and we’re going to support them in whatever they decide.
That’s the change that really needs to happen, especially in these frontline workers.
presenteeism /prɛznˈtiːɪzəm/ – lost productivity that occurs when employees are not fully functioning in the workplace because of an illness, injury, or other condition absenteeism /abs(ə)nˈtiːɪz(ə)m/ – habitual non-presence of an employee at his or her job
Many believe that the problem with staffing issues from a mental health perspective are about Absenteeism – employees staying at home, not coming to work. In reality, the biggest impact on our productivity is from Presenteeism – employees turning up to work but not functioning effectively.
Presenteeism has had a big impact since COVID. Many people who have been stressed or impacted by changes in their home life feel as if they can’t return to the work environment. Whilst Australia has not had such a significant experience of COVID-19 as other parts of the world, the sudden change of autonomy resulting in an inability to make plans, or catch up with friends and family, can really start to increase our levels of anxiety and result in ongoing feelings of low mood.
People are tired! They’re turning up to work, but they are not effectively engaging. They’re not focussed, cannot stay on task and are not churning out the level of work that they were capable of doing before.
It is the Presenteeism that is our biggest concern.
I try and encourage organisations to focus on their ability to engage their employees in understanding mental fitness. We need to build our capability to be able to weather the varying storms and challenges that life throws at us. If we talk about challenges more openly, we expect that people are going to be more open about their mental health, this bodes much better for a positive work environment.
Whether you have a small business or run a large organisation, if you don’t address the issues of people’s mental health, in addition to their physical health, then you are losing an opportunity to help people work more effectively.
The best way we can do that is by making it okay to talk openly about life’s challenges. It isn’t possible to separate our work and home lives altogether. If we are extremely stressed at home then that is going to show in the work we are able to put out. When we have an employer who is understanding of the fact that life is going to throw everyone curve balls, then we are given the space to be able to recover.
Recovering at work is always better than employees being off work. Recognising that presenteeism in those situations is very real, but understood, will help them get back to their best self as fast as they can. The culture is set by the attitude that is present when they are being affected by these issues.
We try and pretend that our people are not humans – but they are!
When we treat them like human beings, we accept that what they tell us on face value is right, and that it has had an impact on them, then we give them an opportunity to be honest and open. We need to ask how we can help them get back to the best that they can be in the work environment.
In doing so, you create a lot of loyalty, buy-in and support.
The Australian minerals sector has maintained a vigilant focus on workplace health and safety. Historically, efforts were directed toward the identification and mitigation of physical safety risk, and the promotion of workplace culture that aims to prevent injury to the individual or their workmates. Over the past few years there has been a widening of this focus to include the wellbeing and mental health of those working in the resources sector. There is now a strong body of evidence that attention to mental health in industry can bring substantial benefits. This approach has been supported in principle by the Minerals Council of Australia in their 2015 ‘Blueprint for Mental Health and Wellbeing’.
41% of FIFO workers don’t seek help due to stigma
The main concern with the approach outlined in this ‘Blueprint’ is that there are a number of areas that have been identified as ‘possible actions that the minerals industry, companies, sites or employees may undertake’. In the past five years, there has been little change in the mental health and wellbeing in the resources sector, mainly because no clear actions were taken. In order to achieve a goal, research shows that you have to ensure that certain criteria are met. The Blueprint provided ideas about improving mental health, but didn’t get into the specifics of ownership for the idea or the specifics of the what, where, when, how, who and why. Without specifics that are measurable, and holding someone to account for them, the chances of success pale into insignificance.
39% of FIFO workers are stressed by lack of services
To achieve real and lasting cultural change for the sector, there must be specific interventions clearly identified that provide guidance about exactly what activities are going to result in improved mental health and wellbeing for the cohort. They require a timeframe for achievement and a plan for getting there. These outcomes need to be measured and monitored for ongoing and iterative improvement.
In fitness, we understand that if a person engages in a 12-week body transformation challenge, they will see many physical and psychological benefits from it. We don’t expect that those benefits will continue if they decide not to maintain their active fitness program and monitor their eating. Yet, we think that if we provide ‘Mental Health First Aid’ or some other one-off training to our people we have ticked the box and they won’t have any ongoing mental health challenges. It’s a ridiculous notion. Maintenance of any skill requires regular use and reinforcement.
Workplace mental health programs have direct benefits in reducing absenteeism and improving productivity and workplace injury claims, alongside indirect benefits to recruitment, retention and staff wellbeing. Programs that address mental health in the workplace can also bring social benefits to the morale and culture of the workplace and to employees and their families. The wider impact of mental health programs in the workplace should not be underestimated. These pathways contribute to the impact on individual health, wellbeing and functioning and contribute to the delivery of broader health benefits to the community.
It’s Not Just Stigma
There is a great deal of focus in the sector that the problems exist due to stigma. Although it may be true that there is a significant level of stigma across the sector, it does not have to be a barrier to help- seeking. In fact, I published research about increasing help-seeking intention in 2018. We can increase help-seeking intention, especially in men, but they need to be hearing the right message.
Sector Lacks Focus
Data on mental health needs within the minerals industry is limited. Research in affiliated sectors has been more robust and some of the outcomes can be extrapolated due to their correlation.
One in five Australian’s report a mental health issue annually, for miner’s it is one in three. That means that there are over 93,000 resources workers (predominantly men) who are likely to be experiencing a mental health issue at any given time. There are several reasons for this including higher than average levels of ex- services personnel, remote working conditions in FIFO/DIDO roles and anecdotal evidence around substance-use. The mental health impacts are not only on the worker, but can have influence on the mental health of their families. The sector employs 2% of the population, but influences over 9% of the population.
Conservative estimates of cost to the industry including lowered productivity are between $320 million – $450 million per year or around $300,000 – $400,000 annually for an average site. However, these numbers were based on the impact of only 10,000 affected employees. The real number is almost 10-fold.
The Solution
In psychological terms we refer to three phases of intervention – promotion, prevention and early intervention. In order to improve the overall mental health of any cohort, we must address all three areas.
The exact interventions utilised in each area require consideration of each individual work environment. In essence, the first step is to undertake a ‘Traumatic Injury Prevention Strategy (TIPS)’ review. This initial piece of work involves review of relevant documentation, in depth discussions with senior staff and provision of a detailed Report that provides insight into what the risk factors are under each of the four areas (People, HR Management, Prevention and Agility). This report outlines a number of Recommended Actions, including the rationale for why these should be taken, backed up by emerging evidence and research.
This provides the organisation with an evidence-based roadmap of options for moving forward, including identification of the options that will afford the quickest return on investment, and improve outcomes for your people into the future.
Recommended actions are aligned with industry specific outcomes combined with the required interventions to ensure that cultural change can be achieved with a clear plan of appropriate timeframes and opportunity for review and iterative adjustments over the course of the project implementation.
Responsibility is Shifting
Implications of poorly managed stressors on the workforce have recently come under International scrutiny. In early 2020, two Director’s of a French Company were found guilty of manslaughter for failing to intervene in the bullying and harassment of a staff member who ultimately took his own life. We know that the resources sector has high rates of suicide amongst it’s employees. How long will it be before these corporations are held to account for their failure to even attempt to improve the mental health of their workers?
Workplace Culture
Research from Beyond Blue highlighted that a dysfunctional workplace is just as likely to cause a person to develop PTSD as being routinely exposed to traumatic experiences.
Male dominated workplace cultures do not support their people to express emotion or share the impact of their experiences openly. The only way that these people can maintain active engagement in the workplace, to which they want to belong, is to repress the impact of these experiences. This action requires the expression of the opposite emotion to suppress it, resulting in more aggressive behaviour in the workplace.
This results in adding further dysfunction to the work environment and over time, this becomes the new ‘norm’ and sets the culture of an organisation.
Cultural Change
Awareness Learning Practice Accountability
Individual corporations need to ensure that these elements are in place, they they want to improve culture and enhance the mental health and wellbeing of their people.
mental fitness /mɛnt(ə)l fɪtnəs/ – a personal framework for understanding how to build wellbeing and having a positive sense of how we feel, think and act
It has only been over the past decade that I have focussed more on my physical fitness, to assist with my health and wellbeing, and manage my injuries. Going to the gym multiple times a week helps me to gain and maintain strength and reduces my pain experience from injuries that I sustained over 15 years ago.
In order to be accepted into frontline service organisations, you must be physically fit. There is an expectation that you will maintain fitness even as you get older, as it is always expected you can meet certain minimum fitness criteria.
This is perfectly understandable considering the role itself requires quite a lot of physical fitness. When fighting a fire, you may have to stand with the hose for lengthy periods of time. Or as a paramedic, you may have to lift someone onto a gurney. Police officers may have to chase a perpetrator down. We know that these roles require a certain level of physical fitness.
However, we also know that these roles expose individuals to traumatic experiences, leaving them in a place of psychological vulnerability. We participate in physical fitness, requiring minimum standards and ongoing work to maintain them. So, why don’t we also practice mental strengthening exercises? Training and regular exercises that support us to understand our risk from exposure to traumatic events and how to minimise this risk.
We need to provide individuals with a mental skills toolbox!
To support physical fitness capacity, we usually follow a program. We have personal trainers; we watch what we eat and how we sleep. We can engage in high energy activities like High Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) or lower intensity exercise like Yoga or Pilates. There are a variety of forms of exercise that can improve and maintain physical fitness and we know that these roles require a minimum level of fitness and we require people to maintain that in order to stay in the job.
We know that people in certain industries are going to end up with psychological challenges because of the work they do. What we don’t seem to understand is that there is a range of mental fitness exercises and tools that they should engage with post exposure.
As an industry, emergency services personnel have been told that their physical health is highly important and must be maintained. Yet, their mental health is not even considered until after it has noticeably deteriorated, usually long after the exposure has occurred. In many cases, the status of a worker’s mental health is not observed or addressed until the individual is in a state in which they are no longer able to work.
This is not to be disparaging of any organisation.
From a psychological perspective, we have only looked at mental health from a reactive position, what to do once these people are broken, to help them heal.
There is a lot that we can do to help them recover, however, there is so much more that we can do to intervene earlier in the process. We can help our workers to become mentally fit before they get exposed to traumatic events and help them maintain that fitness.
When we consider rehabilitation for physical injuries, they may take a few weeks out of the gym, engage with some physiotherapy, then get back to exercise ASAP to build up muscle strength. So why don’t we help people to understand the same concept can be applied when we are recovering from a psychological injury?
There are so many things that we can do to help people build mental fitness and prevent them from developing post-traumatic injuries. It is frustrating that we don’t do more to help our people build mental fitness and organisations are missing a significant opportunity to improve the capability of their people.
Just as we expose ourselves to new ways of training our physical body, we need to understand that there are new ways of being able to train our psychological mindset as well.
sexual assault /sek-shəl -ə-ˈsȯlt/ – illegal sexual contact that usually involves force upon a person without consent, or is inflicted upon a person who is incapable of giving consent
Over the last few weeks, there has been a lot of focus in the media about sexual assault, especially when women are waiting a significant period of time before making a report.
Delays in reporting sexual assault are not uncommon. Many women feel unable to speak up when the assault happens, especially if it has occurred in their work environment, or in a country town or small community. They often feel so ashamed that they struggle to find the inner strength to report. This phenomenon is exacerbated exponentially if women are intoxicated in any way.
Unfortunately, society still places the blame on women for sexual assault.
It is really hard to believe that 50 years after the ‘so-called’ sexual revolution, Australian women are still being chastised for being too attractive or available late into the night.
It is unreasonable to believe that by being intoxicated, a woman’s decision making ability would be so significantly impaired that she couldn’t know whether or not she wanted to engage in sexual intimacy. Many high level men in our country have implied that if a young woman were intoxicated then maybe they don’t remember that they said or did things that implied that they did want a sexual interaction.
Is it any surprise then that women find it difficult to report sexual assault in Australia?
Despite the fact that they feel that their body was violated in a way that was unwanted, they feel ashamed by the belief that somehow they were to blame because they were intoxicated by alcohol or other drugs.
They blame themselves thinking if they had not been intoxicated, then this may not have happened to them. We have this perception, and there is reasonable truth to it, that our inhibitions are impacted by drugs and alcohol and we could have been more forthright if we had not consumed anything.
This is a major issue for our society in general, because having a couple of drinks does not give anybody an excuse to claim that they didn’t know what they were doing, or that they didn’t recognise that they were doing something that was unwanted.
Sexual assaults happen in many ways, but the responsibility for the unwelcome attention should not be placed on women. As a socialist democracy Australia supports equality under law, yet the responsibility for sexual assault still seems to firmly rest upon women and asking the question of whether or not they said ‘No’! Why don’t we ask men whether or not a woman said ‘Yes’?
I find young people appear to have greater emotional intelligence and seem to be more aware of the importance of consent. They have better clarity around a ‘code’ that if someone is intoxicated, then you don’t make a move. It is considered really ‘poor form’ with many young people if you were to be seen taking advantage of somebody who was intoxicated.
Women are entitled to feel safe in their own community.
It does not matter if they are dressed attractively or if someone perceives them as ‘sexy’. This isn’t an excuse. It does not give people the right to step past a certain boundary.
Rather than asking whether or not a woman said no, we should be asking whether she explicitly said yes! The more we educate men to understand that unless they get an explicit “Yes, this is okay”, then it absolutely is not. And we cannot stress that enough!
It might be time for a YES Movement. That men require a #YES2UNDRESS
A movement that encourages women to be open and say “Yes, I agree that this is something I want to do” or it doesn’t happen. We need to flip the onus of responsibility to one that says unless explicit consent is given, then it is an automatic no go zone.
This is not an easy topic. It raises quite a few issues for many women who have found they have had their bodies imposed upon. It does not matter how they were dressed, where they were, what time of day or whether they were intoxicated. None of these factors gives anybody an excuse to take something that does not belong to them.
If you need any support with regards to anything I’ve discussed today, please reach out to your rape crisis centre or any other form of counselling support.
It is time that we learned that unless there is a ‘Yes’, then it is automatically, ‘No’!
self-determination /self-ditərməˈnāshən/ – the process whereby a person can control their own life
In order to prevent staff from staying away for an extended period when on stress leave, and ultimately lodging a workers compensation claim, I recommend to organisations that we need to intervene early and contact them within the first 48 hours.
This contact shouldn’t necessarily be made by somebody from their work area, especially not if the person has an issue with a particular member of the team. It can be someone from a different area or someone independent altogether. There just needs to be someone who is checking in with them, asking if everything is okay and if they like to talk about it.
These individuals need someone to listen to their story, not someone who is going to take sides.
They might say they are unhappy with their manager or someone else and, in reality, the manager might not actually be doing anything wrong. That individual may just be really stressed by the situation they are in and misconstrue what is happening in the work environment. Realistically, it doesn’t actually matter – the individual who has the problem needs to be heard and feel validated about their perspective.
Such an approach will give the individual a sense that they are valuable to the organisation, and whether they return to that specific work environment or not, your organisation is still going to benefit from them remaining within the business. If people are excluded from the workplace, their mental health is going to deteriorate.
There are different rules and regulations, depending on what state you are in, about the obligations we have to remain in touch with individuals who are on stress leave. Generally, regardless of the obligations, many managers report feeling uncomfortable about reaching out to that person, in fear they are going to make the situation worse or will not know how to deal with the person’s perspective, the information they may provide, or their mood.
Alternative support options
I often recommend that organisations, especially larger organisations, set up a range of alternatives for contacts that these individuals can speak to in the early stages of stress leave. There may be a team of external counsellors or providers that the individual can access facilitated by the organisation or there might be an Employee Assistance Program (EAP). Perhaps your organisation could consider if there is an alternative way of providing an individual access to funding that enables them to access whatever support they might need to help them recover from this stressful situation and return to work.
We all want to support validated therapeutic processes provided by counsellors or psychologists, but for some people, those options may not work for them. They may just need access to de-stressing through natural therapies or massage, acupuncture or attending a mindfulness course.
Certain areas of science might say that these options aren’t ‘valid’, however we shouldn’t be judging what is valid or not for an individual. Rather, we need to allow the injured worker to determine what approach is best for themselves. Self-determination for their own recovery. This approach enables the individual to feel they are being supported by the organisation to get better in whatever way works for them.
Need for Self-Determination
If organisations utilised this approach, I believe that we would find far fewer people would then take the next step and submit a workers’ compensation claim.
In Australia, a lot of the workers’ compensation claims are made because there is no acceptance of differing perspectives. We are insistent that we find somebody at fault and this approach often places a person in a defensive position which can manifest as overt aggression or silent stone-walling. This process exacerbates the injury by forcing the person to defend their experience and due to our history of the concrete thinking applied in our ‘black and white’ legal system, we don’t give the individual any opportunity to have self-determination in what it is that they do to recover.
The concept of self-determination has become better known through our approach to Indigenous affairs in Australia. We support indigenous peoples self-determine what is required to improve outcomes for themselves and their community.
I believe that if we took this approach with our employees, we would find that they would feel more empowered in their own recovery and would return to work quicker. Ideally, we would give them ample opportunity to access the help that they needed without getting to the point of needing to make a workers compensation claim.
Self-Determination does work!
If you’re not sure about the validity of such an approach, just have a look at what Victoria Police implemented about 18 months ago. Pre-COVID, they put in place a fund for individual members to access up to three months worth of support to access therapy, in relation to any area of their life, without needing to seek approval and without it forming part of their personnel record.
We know that when we give people the option to access the support that they need for themselves, and provide them a range of options to support their recovery, they feel more in control of their challenges. This approach empowers them to feel validated by the organisation and, in turn, their recovery.
I can’t stress enough, how important it is to give people the opportunity to have a sense of autonomy over their recovery.
malinger /məˈlɪŋɡə/ – Pretending to be ill in order to escape duty or work
I hear the term thrown around at lot, particularly when I work with HR teams who have people on workers compensation. I find it challenging that many HR managers believe that there are many people who malinger.
As a person who talks about how we might approach workers compensation differently, my brain can’t help but question the assumption. Are they really malingerers? Or are we operating on an assumption because we think people should return to work in a specified timeframe? If they don’t comply with that timeframe, we assume they are malingering.
From a psychological perspective, if I am trying to assess behaviour utilising the DSM criterion for whether someone is truly malingering, the decision-making process is actually quite challenging and fraught with difficulty. There are certain decision points where the absence of information leads to an assumption that a person is lying. At every point of a decision tree, you expect an option of yes or no – however, in this type of assessment my only option is ‘Yes’, leading to this person is a liar. Then my only decision is what ‘sort’ of liar! It is completely biased, and I believe that it unreasonably assumes that the person is guilty until proven innocent.
I find the whole notion about malingering to be quite overused in many organisations.
Years ago, I worked with Centrelink and many of my co-workers would become very cynical about people who walked in the door. I decided that if I ever reached the point where I felt that everybody walking in the door was there for a reason that wasn’t real or valid, it was time that I moved on.
I think this happens in a lot of organisations. We get used to hearing about people who are off on workers compensation leave, especially if you work in a HR area, and it is very difficult to determine who is legitimate.
But I wonder why it matters. Why do we feel the need to judge people and their circumstances? I find that if you approach people with dignity and respect and take what they tell you on face value, then people are just pleased that somebody is listening to them and taking time to understand what their challenges are. They really do appreciate the fact that these people are willing to help them.
I wonder whether this perception that we have of ‘malingering’ is just that, a perception.
It’s time to bust the myth!
2020 has given us a great example of how we need to react to situations when we believe that it will cause bigger problems. COVID-19 itself is invisible, but we know that it is dangerous for us and our community.
What if we accepted that anybody who has to go off on workers compensation must be really unwell and truly have a psychological or physiological injury. Then we could treat them with the same respect that we would if somebody told us that they had to stay home because of COVID. We can accept that there is a real and present danger to this person’s mental or physical health if they were to return to the workplace.
What if we approach them as if everything that they said was true, because that is, after all, their experience?
I wonder if that would make a significant enough difference that we would stop believing that people are making workers compensation claims because they think it’s ‘easy money’. I have worked with many claimants and there is absolutely nothing easy about it. In fact, it is probably one of the most demoralising experiences a person can go through and the process itself could create a traumatic injury.
I want to challenge you to try approaching these people differently. Accept what they are telling you is their reality. As a fellow human being, they deserve respect and encouragement for having the courage to stand up for themselves, in the face of a system that treats them like a criminal.